Plenty of people manage their own tax affairs perfectly well, and for some, an accountant is an unnecessary cost. For others, trying to do it alone means paying more tax than they need to, missing deadlines, or getting a letter from HMRC they do not know how to answer. This article explains when you are likely to need an accountant, when you probably do not, and what to look for when choosing one.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and reflects HMRC and Companies House requirements at the time of writing in November 2026. Every business and individual is different. Always seek advice tailored to your own circumstances.

The Quick Answer

You are not legally required to use an accountant. You can file your own tax return and, if you run a company, your own accounts.

If you are employed with simple savings, or a sole trader with straightforward income, you may be able to manage yourself.

If you run a limited company, are a landlord with several properties, are VAT registered, employ staff, or are selling a business, a good accountant usually saves more than they cost.

Anyone can call themselves an accountant, so check for a professional qualification such as ACCA.

When You Can Probably Do It Yourself

If you are employed, your only other income is a little bank interest, and you do not need to complete a tax return, you probably do not need an accountant.

If you are a sole trader with simple income, few expenses and no employees, you can file your own tax return online, as long as you keep good records and understand what you can claim. Our article on how much tax to set aside is a good place to start.

When an Accountant Usually Pays for Themselves

If you run a limited company

A company must file annual accounts with Companies House, a Corporation Tax return with HMRC, and a confirmation statement every year, as explained in our guide to limited company filing requirements. The accounts must follow accounting standards, and directors are personally responsible for getting them right. An accountant can also help you decide the most tax efficient way to pay yourself, which alone can save thousands of pounds a year.

If you are a landlord

From April 2027, landlords and sole traders with qualifying income over £30,000 must keep digital records and send quarterly updates to HMRC under Making Tax Digital. Tax on rental profits is also rising, so how your properties are owned and financed matters more than ever.

If you are VAT registered or employ staff

VAT returns and payroll both have strict rules, deadlines and penalties, and mistakes are easy to make.

If your business is growing

Deciding whether to stay as a sole trader or form a company, as explained in our guide to sole trader or limited company, is one of the most valuable decisions an accountant can help with.

If HMRC writes to you

HMRC is carrying out more compliance checks than ever, as explained in our article on HMRC investigations. Having an accountant who knows your affairs can make a check much quicker and less stressful.

The Cost of Getting It Wrong

Missing deadlines is expensive. According to HMRC, there is a £100 penalty for a late Self Assessment return, rising with daily penalties after three months. Corporation Tax late filing penalties doubled from April 2026, as explained in our article on Corporation Tax penalties. Companies House also charges late filing penalties of between £150 and £1,500 for a private company, depending on how late the accounts are.

Missed deadlinePenalty
Late Self Assessment return£100, rising with daily penalties after three months
Late Corporation Tax filingDoubled from April 2026
Late accounts at Companies House (private company)£150 to £1,500, depending on how late the accounts are

Worked Examples

Worked Example 1: A Freelancer Who Manages Alone

Tom is a self employed photographer with profits of £24,000, few expenses and no employees. He keeps a simple spreadsheet, files his own return on time, and sets money aside for tax. For Tom, an accountant may not be necessary yet, although a one off review to check he is claiming all his expenses could be worthwhile.

Worked Example 2: A Director Paying Too Much Tax

Leila runs a consultancy company with profits of £90,000 and pays herself entirely through salary because she was not sure about dividends. A review of her pay, using a small salary, dividends and employer pension contributions, could reduce her combined tax and National Insurance by several thousand pounds a year, well above the cost of an accountant.

Worked Example 3: A Landlord Facing Making Tax Digital

Gary owns three rental flats with rent of £45,000 a year. From April 2027, he must keep digital records and send quarterly updates. He also needs to understand how the new property income rates affect him. An accountant can set up his software, handle the quarterly updates and make sure his mortgage interest and expenses are claimed correctly.

How to Choose an Accountant

Check their qualifications. Chartered Certified Accountants are members of ACCA, are regulated, must hold professional indemnity insurance and must keep their knowledge up to date.

Look for experience in your sector, whether that is property, healthcare, construction, online retail or professional services.

Ask what is included in the fee, how often you will hear from them, and whether they offer advice as well as compliance.

Choose someone who explains things in plain English, and who you feel comfortable calling with a question.

What Affects the Cost?

Fees depend on what you need. The main factors are whether you are a sole trader or a company, your turnover, how many transactions you have, whether you are VAT registered or run payroll, how well your records are kept, and whether you want ongoing advice. A good accountant will give you a clear fixed fee before starting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it a legal requirement to have an accountant?

No. You can file your own returns and accounts, but you are responsible for getting them right.

Does a limited company need an accountant?

Not legally, but most directors use one, because company accounts and tax returns are more complex and directors are personally responsible for them.

Can an accountant save me money?

Often, yes, through tax planning, making sure you claim everything you are entitled to, and avoiding penalties.

What qualifications should an accountant have?

Look for a recognised professional body membership, such as ACCA, which means they are regulated and insured.

When should I get an accountant?

Ideally before you start a business, form a company, buy a rental property or make a big financial decision, rather than after the year end.

Do you work with clients outside Hertfordshire?

Yes. CoreAcc Accountants is based in Borehamwood and works with clients across Hertfordshire, North London and beyond.

What CoreAcc Accountants Can Help You With

CoreAcc Accountants is an ACCA accredited firm based in Borehamwood, working with sole traders, landlords, limited companies and individuals across Hertfordshire and North London. We prepare accounts and tax returns, run payroll and VAT, handle Making Tax Digital, and give proactive advice on structure, pay and tax planning, all for a clear, agreed fee.

Get in Touch

Not sure whether you need an accountant? Contact CoreAcc Accountants for an initial conversation, and we will tell you honestly whether we can save you more than we cost.

CoreAcc Accountants is an ACCA accredited firm of Chartered Certified Accountants based in Borehamwood, Hertfordshire. This article was published in November 2026 and reflects HMRC and Companies House requirements at the time of writing. It does not constitute professional or legal advice. Always seek specific advice tailored to your individual circumstances.